Module 4 Lesson Plan 2 - Cross Cultural Psychology


They Settled America
Part I - Hutterrite Culture

 

Review Class/Internet Activities Summary Homework All People Smile...

 

Daily Language Blooper

Colgate introduced a toothpaste in France called Cue, the name of a notorious porno magazine. webofculture.com

Review - Group Thoughts

1.  During the first third of this course we have defined culture, and concentrated on observing cultures in North America.

2.  Because the greatest learning sometimes comes as the result of the greatest contrast, we have at the same time made a deliberate study of the culture of Japan.

Class/Internet Activities

1. Watch excerpts from The Hutterites and find similarities and differences between the Amish and the Hutterites in America.
2. Optional Activity: Read and discuss Anthony Brandt's article - "in Selfish-Pursuit:  The Road to Happiness is Often Paved With Guilt."
3. Visit the link to the First Book Report and discuss its requirements.

      1.  Watch excerpts from The Hutterites and find similarities and differences between the Amish and the Hutterites in America. 

       2A.  Optional Activity:
In 1776, a Virginian named Thomas Jefferson wrote:
"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and pursuit of Happiness."  Yet children, women, slaves, criminals, the insane, and American Indians were not included.

       2B.  Today's class gives you an opportunity to reflect on what happiness means to you.  Using a handout from Explorations in American Culture, pages 30-34, your instructor may introduce you to  Anthony Brandt, who will argue: "Happiness at the time of the Declaration was not a state of mind that one pursued in and for oneself, but a version of the common good, an idea of general human felicity that one pursued both for oneself and for all. Jefferson was trying to establish the idea that government has no right to stand in the way of our pursuit of felicity so conceived." - American Culture Read the article and return it to your instructor.

       2C.  See if your class members agree with the statement that "Certainly the native American Indian did not participate in the "general human felicity that one pursued both for oneself and for all."  On the other hand, certain collectivist societies, the Amish and the Hutterites seem to extend among one another, and to have been afforded to some degree, the kind of tolerance embodied in Brandt's statement.

      3.  Visit the link to the First Book Report and discuss its requirements.  The link to the book reports is on the Course Homepage.

 

Has Your Travel Agent Told You?

A man called, furious about a Florida package we did. I asked what was wrong with the vacation in Orlando. He said he was expecting an ocean-view room. I tried to explain that is not possible, since Orlando is in the middle of the state. He replied, "Don't lie to me. I looked on the map and Florida is a very thin state."

crosscultural.com

Summary

          1.  Those who came to America have frequently remained ethnocentric and stripped persons unlike themselves from the dignity to which their own culture entitles them.

           2.  Yet American extends religious tolerance insofar as possible, and purports in its Declaration of Independence that all are entitled to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.  The Declaration of Independence as learned cultural behavior is embodied in subsequent language worldwide, amongst ourselves and even our enemies.  Ho Chi Minh espoused the language of Jefferson three times in letters to President Harry Truman asking for a U.S. guarantee for an independent Viet Nam.   President Truman instead permitted French allies to return the area to French control.  Frustrated, but undefeated, Ho Chi Minh then gave his allegiance to Communist-inspired doctrine, with the ultimate consequences inherent for America's foray into the Viet Nam War.

           3.  Happiness can be either a personal or a collective value.  The Hutterite people seem repressed by conventional Western thinking, and yet their society seems destined to survive if given the chance, while America continues to generate its own small proportion of disaffected peoples. 

Homework

1.  Read Chapter Twelve "Was Hunger the Motivation for Aztec Cannibalism?" pages 62-66 in Cross-Cultural Perspectives in America.  Answer the following questions in your notebook:

1. Is there evidence that the Aztecs had a dietary need for protein that normal food sources could not meet?
2. What argument is given for the theory that cannibalism was most likely motivated by religious beliefs?

2.  Read Chapter 10 "The Dilemma of Virtue" pages 195-227 in The Chrysanthemum and the Sword.  Answer the following questions in your notebook: 

3. The Japanese do not see life as a stage on which forces of good contend with forces of evil.  Explain the circles of life seen by the Japanese and how this contrasts with the Western idea of morality. (pages 195-199)
4. Although not appreciated in Western literature, explain the significance of the Tale of the Forty-Seven Ronin to a Japanese audience.  (pages 198-207)
5. What purposes are served by the Rescript for Soldiers and Sailors in Japan?  (pages 209-214)
6. Discuss the roles of shame, guilt, and self-respect have in Japanese and American cultures.
7. If one grew up in Japan, what impact does leaving Japan seem to have on those who further their education in Amercia?  (pages 225-228)

       

Customary Behaviors (Other than my own)

Canada (Western and Atlantic Provinces)

A firm handshake plus direct eye contact is the standard form of greeting in Canada. Men should shake hands with women if they offer their hand, but many women will just say 'hello,' perhaps with a nod of the head, and not shake hands.

 

bulletDistances are farther apart than in Latin America or the Far East. When conversing, people will stand about a half meter apart.

 

bulletThere is little or no casual touching. The only exceptions are that good male friends may occasionally pat the other's back, close relatives may put their arms around another's shoulder, and good female friends may occasionally hug when greeting each other after long intervals.

 

bulletGood eye contact is important, whether it is during business or social conversation.

 

bulletIn social situations, men will usually rise when women enter a room.

 

bulletCanadians in these provinces are described as 'friendly,' 'somewhat reserved,' and "on the conservative side.' Therefore, excessive gesturing is not common.

 

bulletMen will sit with legs crossed, and all three forms are common and accepted: crossed at the ankles, crossed at the knees, and having one ankle crossed on the other knee.

 

bulletBeckoning is done by raising the hand, fingers pointing up and palm inward, and motioning the fingers toward one's face or body. This contrasts with the beckoning signal in many other parts of the world where the arm is extended, palm down, and the fingers are moved in a scratching motion.

 

bulletTo beckon a waiter, just raise the hand at or above head level. To signal that you want the check, make a motion with the hands as if you are signing a piece of paper.

 

bulletCanadians may eat with either the continental style (fork constantly in the left hand) or the American style (where the fork moves back and forth between the hands).

 

bulletMost of the popular gestures shown will be known, used and fully understood in Canada. The one exception might be the 'hook 'em horns' gesture known in the United States (especially in Texas), and in Italy, Africa, and Brazil.

webofculture.com

 

"All people smile in the same language" ---- Unknown

The social utopia envisioned by dreamers has been attempted in America.  Amish and Hutterites are cultures that have in part, succeeded in this country.